Who is Indian? Reservation culture vs. DakotaTweet
By: Dr. Erich Longie
In one of my blogs I had asked the question, Whos Indian? To understand my answer, you have to recall the manner in which I asked the question. In my blog I insinuated that if you did not speak your tribal language, if you did not follow your tribes traditions, if you did not attend pow- wows, if you were not raised in poverty, if you did not follow Indian Time, if you did not booze all night, etc., then you were not Indian.
When a wide ranging, freedom loving people who were defeated militarily is placed within the confines of a small piece of land with no viable means of survival other then depending on US Government, they often lose the majority of their customs and culture; especially when those customs are very dependent on a wide-ranging, freedom loving (go anywhere) lifestyle to begin with. With the loss of their customs and culture, they become susceptible to all the psychological ills (emotional and mental) of a military defeated people i.e. alcoholism, depression, loss of identity, no pride in their heritage etc. This type of dysfunctional behavior sometimes becomes the norm for certain individuals.
This is what happened to the majority of Indians who were placed on Reservations. They succumbed to the psychological ills of a conquered people and became dysfunctional individuals.
Fortunately for us, against all odds, and in spite of the horrible conditions that existed on Indian reservations, a few of our ancestors managed to hang onto their customs and passed this sacred knowledge down throughout the centuries.
A few weeks ago my older brother Phillip John Young (PJ) lost his valiant fight against cancer and journeyed to the Spirit World. At his wake and funeral, Father Chuck (a Catholic Priest for Seven Dolors Church in Fort Totten, ND) talked about Reservation Culture vs. Dakota Culture. I was fascinated by what Father Chuck had to say because what he said is parallel to what I have been saying and writing about in my Tribal Leaders Institute.
After my brothers burial, when we were eating, I asked Father Chuck if I could interview him. I wanted him to expand on the Reservation Culture vs. Dakota Culture sermon he gave. He agreed, so we met at my home. Here is the gist of what he said about Reservation Culture vs. Dakota Culture:
Individuals who practice reservation culture instead of their Dakota culture avoid the reality of life. Most of these individuals live a dysfunctional lifestyle and it affects how they deal with stress. They have no identity, because they are not operating within a Dakota Culture framework, nor within a Christian framework.
Father Chuck then drew a circle. He explained the middle of the circle is you. The top of the circle represents your higher power. On the right side is the Physical World (Creator) the bottom of the circle is your inner self and the left side is other people and animals. He explained to me that who you are is how you relate to all of the elements in the circle. He reiterated that those individuals who do not follow Dakota or Christian values have negative relationships with the other elements of the circle.
Very quickly, I drew my own circle. In the middle I put Joe The Tribal Worker (my fictional tribal worker), his higher power is money (greed), his Physical World consists of vindictiveness, lying, and stealing. Joes inner self is using humor as form of denial, he practices Indian Time, and he has no self-honesty. He sees other people merely as way to accomplish his devious goals.
I informed Father Chuck that Charles Eastman, the first Dakota physician, said something to the effect that Christianity and todays civilization are incompatible. However, Christianity and Dakota spirituality are basically one in the same. Father Chuck said he has been saying the same thing for many years. He then asked where I got that information. I showed him the book, The Soul of the Indian, by Charles Eastman.
Now back to my question, Whos Indian? Here is the standard (easy) answer to that question: Each tribe has their own criteria to determine who is technically eligible to be enrolled in their tribe. Therefore, individuals who are officially enrolled in a tribe are Indian, at least by U.S. Government standards.
However, in regards to my tribe, I personally I agree with Father Chucks answer when I asked him whos Indian (Dakota). Here was his response…
Saying, Im more Indian than you, is used to put somebody down. You need to demonstrate you are [Indian] instead of saying you are Indian. Its not the degree of blood; its your spirituality that you ordinarily receive from your family that determines who you are. If you did not receive it from your family then it is hard to learn it when you are older. You should understand and practice your traditions instead of just talking about them. The person who does this is a Dakota. Other people may be Dakota on paper- they may have the genes of an Indian (Dakota) and they may be registered as an Indian but these others take advantage of being a Dakota, using it as an excuse for dysfunctional behavior. Often Indians accuse other Indians of not being Indian! You cant go back to living in Teepees. Having a job, an education, electricity, and running water in your home does not make you a white person. Its how you act, how you talk, its your spirituality, and how these affect your relationships everyday. Thats what makes you a Dakota.
Every now and then I have doubts about what I am doing (workshops on Dakota traditional values). Are people really that bad? I have to ask myself, when I hear the stories of all the corrupt and unethical behavior that is common on most reservations. I feel so helpless. Then I run into someone like Chuck and he reinforces my belief that change is badly needed here on our reservation.
This past Sunday, I traveled to another reservation for a Book Party. At the Book Party we discussed the book Rebuilding Native Nations. The book accurately identifies issues on Indian Reservations and offers solutions to them. We discussed how the contents of the book described our reservations and how the solutions would make a better life for all tribal members. Inevitability, the discussion turned to the shenanigans of tribal employees (council members, governing board members and entry level workers). As I sat and listened to their stories and added a few of my own, I thought it is amazing how much unethical behavior we Indians accept without doing anything about it.
When they talked about their own experiences, I was pleased to see that every now and then one of them would turn to me and in a teasing way ask, is that ethical? It was friendly teasing, because I promote my ethics workshops all of the time.
Years ago, when I first became Academic Dean at our tribal college, I attended a training seminar where I heard a piece of advice from the trainer that would guide me throughout my years at the college.
Before you do something ask yourself this question: how would it impact the students? If the answer is negatively then dont do it, it is as simple as that, the presenter said.
That is what we should do before we do act. We should ask ourselves, Is this ethical? If it is not, then dont do it. It is as simple as that.
Let me close by airing a pet peeve of mine. I am extremely irritated by individuals my age and older who claim to be traditional. They attend or hold ceremonies (sweats, sun dances, naming, etc.) yet they do not follow the Dakota values of courage, honesty, perseverance and generosity. It would be nice to see a person who participates in ceremonies such as sweats, also practice these four values. Visa versa, it would be nice to see those people who practice the four values of courage, honesty, perseverance and generosity get involved in ceremonies such as sweats, name giving, Sun Dances and other ceremonies. We need to practice our culture in its entirety, not just the parts that are the most comfortable and pleasing to us.